FORMAmrhart.org · curriculum into cognitive architecture
Back to the format index

Analytical architecture·High cognitive demand·one lesson

Argument Builder

Construct a defensible judgment by linking claims, selected evidence, warrants, counterclaims, and qualification.

Knowledge
Argumentative · Evidential · Evaluative · Comparative
Sequence
Guided Construction · Independent Judgment
Interaction
Medium

An argument builder makes the architecture of reasoning inspectable before prose is written. Students decide what each piece of evidence does, compare rival explanations, and qualify a final claim to match the strength of the case.

01How the architecture unfolds

  1. Draft a provisional answer.
  2. Sort evidence by the claim it could support.
  3. Write the warrant connecting each evidence item to the claim.
  4. Build and answer the strongest counterclaim.
  5. Rank factors and qualify the final judgment.

02The work on each side

Teacher moves

  • Ask what each evidence item proves
  • Remove evidence that does no argumentative work
  • Model qualification rather than false certainty

Student moves

  • Select
  • Connect
  • Counter
  • Rank
  • Qualify

03What would count as learning?

  • Every selected evidence item has an explicit warrant
  • The final judgment responds to a counterclaim and reflects relative weight

04Across the curriculum

History

Why Weimar democracy collapsed

Rank structural weakness, economic crisis, political violence, and elite decisions while showing interaction.

Media Studies

Representation

Build a judgment about how a text constructs power through form, context, and omission.