FORMAmrhart.org · curriculum into cognitive architecture
Back to the format index

Decision architecture·High cognitive demand·one lesson

Decision Room

Place students inside a bounded decision with incomplete information, competing priorities, and real consequences.

Knowledge
Evaluative · Causal · Ethical · Transfer
Sequence
Disciplinary Application · Independent Judgment · Transfer
Interaction
High

A decision room converts contextual knowledge into constrained judgment. Students must choose at the historical or disciplinary moment, justify priorities, and then compare their decision with consequences they could not fully know.

01How the architecture unfolds

  1. Define the role, moment, and objective.
  2. Issue the evidence pack and constraints.
  3. Require priorities before options are chosen.
  4. Make and defend the decision.
  5. Reveal consequences and audit the reasoning without hindsight.

02The work on each side

Teacher moves

  • Police hindsight
  • Introduce only authentic constraints
  • Separate decision quality from eventual outcome

Student moves

  • Prioritise
  • Trade off
  • Decide
  • Defend
  • Audit

03What would count as learning?

  • Students cite constraints in their justification
  • Students can distinguish a poor outcome from poor reasoning

04Across the curriculum

History

January 1933

Advise President Hindenburg using only information available before Hitler's appointment.

Economics

Inflation policy

Choose a policy mix while balancing prices, employment, debt, and political feasibility.